Showing posts with label freedom. Show all posts
Showing posts with label freedom. Show all posts

Friday, 8 June 2018

Threat? What threat?


In 1996, two British nurses living in Saudi Arabia were convicted of the murder of a fellow nurse, Yvonne Gilford. Like most foreign workers, they lived within a gated, 'secure' Compound. To most observers, their guilt was doubtful, and there was talk of a Saudi security guard seen in the area where the nurses had their rooms.  

The women's motive was supposedly something to do with a passionate lesbian love affair. To most of us, the idea that middle-aged women might murder for passion seems so unlikely as to be ludicrous.  (Gilford was fifty-nine.)  But the Saudi religion is Islam, and Islam has a very odd idea of female sexuality.  

Another possible motive was theft, and one of the nurses supposedly used the credit card of the victim.  

The murderers confessed (under coercion,) were sentenced, one to death by beheading, but both were later returned to Britain. 

Most of the world thought they'd been framed.    

But whether they were guilty or not is not what I wanted to talk about. Some years afterward, I worked with another medical professional, who had lived and worked in the same facility at the same time, and she told me that 'all of them there' were convinced that the accused nurses were undoubtedly guilty, and in a 'wise' sort of a voice, she told me that people will do anything for money.

But what I think is that it would have been too threatening a thought that anyone could be at risk of being framed for murder while in a country with such a different justice system, and far prefer to think that the two were guilty.  They felt safer that way. A lot safer. 


Tommy Robinson
It is akin to the reaction to the punishment of those who fall foul of the authorities because they speak too much truth.  

Tommy Robinson had been harassed for years because he spoke of the damage that the booming numbers of Muslim immigrants were doing to his home suburb of Luton, (London) and to make it worse, he spoke loudly about the Pakistani Muslim rape gangs (usually referred to as 'grooming gangs')  that were ignored for decades by the police.  

He is now in prison on what appears to most of the world to be a remarkably feeble pretext.  



But many, maybe most, people are saying that he knew he was doing the wrong thing and deserved to be locked up. It does not make one feel safe to think that the police and your government might imprison a person for too much truth-telling.  It does not make one feel safe to think that your formerly free and democratic nation is quickly turning into a totalitarian police state. 

We are like the three monkeys when we choose not to see what is happening. 




But it is vital we do see, before our freedom is gone. 

To quote Adolf Hitler - 'The best way to take control of a people and control them utterly is to take a little of their freedom at a time, to erode rights by a thousand tiny and almost imperceptible reductions. In this way, the people will not see those rights and freedoms being removed until past the point at which these changes cannot be reversed."



The edging toward the loss of free speech is happening in many places.  It is happening through persuasion, through 'education' especially at universities, and it is happening through coercion.  Occasionally, I still see someone say that being 'politically correct' is merely to do with politeness.  But it is far more than that.

When we cannot address the lunacy of having men who claim they are women competing in women's sport at a professional level without being accused of 'transphobia,' when we cannot speak of the ill effects of mass immigration without being accused of being 'racist,' and when we cannot talk of the threat posed by Islamic terrorism without being 'Islamophobic,' then we have lost our free speech.  

For the moment, in most places, criticism is as far as it goes, though even that is enough to  bring most of us into line.  But more and more countries are making 'hate speech' a crime punishable by a prison term. Oddly, this is not being used to control a Muslim imam calling for violence toward infidels, instead it is being used to silence those who criticise those Muslim imams who are calling for violence toward infidels.  

We are well on the way to losing our rights and freedoms, just as Hitler described. 

We must wake up, look around, read those articles many prefer to avoid, do not take as gospel the politically correct waffle you see on the ABC and like media, and start to reassert our rights.  Only if we use our rights will we manage to retain them.  I don't think it is too late.












Saturday, 3 May 2014

Changes to the Racial Discrimination Act


Australia.










The Racial Discrimination Act 1975, as it stands,  stifles free speech, and limits the capacity to solve social problems because discussion has to be so carefully expressed that it becomes useless.  

There are changes proposed that would remove the clause that allows a person to make a complaint because they feel 'offended.' In other words, because their feelings are hurt. Unlike the laws against slander or libel, being factual in the 'offensive' statement is no defence.

The changes retain and strengthen the law against incitement to violence against a person because of his/her race, and against intimidation. 

This is what is proposed: 

Attorney-General for Australia
Minister for the Arts
Senator the Hon George Brandis QC

Government Media Release, 25th March, 2014.
Racial Discrimination Act


25 March 2014

The Government Party Room this morning approved reforms to the Racial Discrimination Act 1975 (the Act), which will strengthen the Act’s protections against racism, while at the same time removing provisions which unreasonably limit freedom of speech.

The legislation will repeal section 18C of the Act, as well as sections 18B, 18D, and 18E.

A new section will be inserted into the Act which will preserve the existing protection against intimidation and create a new protection from racial vilification.  This will be the first time that racial vilification is proscribed in Commonwealth legislation sending a clear message that it is unacceptable in the Australian community.

I have always said that freedom of speech and the need to protect people from racial vilification are not inconsistent objectives. Laws which are designed to prohibit racial vilification should not be used as a vehicle to attack legitimate freedoms of speech.

This is an important reform and a key part of the Government’s freedom agenda. It sends a strong message about the kind of society that we want to live in where freedom of speech is able to flourish and racial vilification and intimidation are not tolerated.

Exposure Draft
Freedom of speech (Repeal of S. 18C) Bill 2014

The Racial Discrimination Act 1975 is amended as follows:

1.       Section 18C is repealed.

2.       Sections 18B, 18D and 18E are also repealed.

3.       The following section is inserted:

 “ It is unlawful for a person to do an act, otherwise than in private, if: the act is reasonably likely:  to vilify another person or a group of persons; or  to intimidate another person or a group of persons,

and the act is done because of the race, colour or national or ethnic origin of that person or that group of persons.

2.       For the purposes of this section:   vilify means to incite hatred against a person or a group of persons; intimidate means to cause fear of physical harm to a person or to the property of a person or to the members of a group of persons.

3.       Whether an act is reasonably likely to have the effect specified in sub-section (1)(a) is to be determined by the standards of an ordinary reasonable member of the Australian community, not by the standards of any particular group within the Australian community.

4.       This section does not apply to words, sounds, images or writing spoken, broadcast, published or otherwise communicated in the course of participating in the public discussion of any political, social, cultural, religious, artistic, academic or scientific matter.”
(a few minor punctuation points of the above have been changed from the original direct copy) 

Particularly important points: 
 
'Laws which are designed to prohibit racial vilification should not be used as a vehicle to attack legitimate freedoms of speech.'
 
and  Whether an act is reasonably likely to (vilify or intimidate) is to be determined by the standards of an ordinary reasonable member of the Australian community, not by the standards of any particular group within the Australian community.
 
In essence, the changes to the act would mean that  a person or group cannot complain merely because they feel offended or insulted.  


The act as it stands, does indeed limit free speech.

It limits little things  -  I was standing next to my fishpond, and talking aloud to the goldfish. One was black, and I said something like, 'Hi there, black feller.' Now 'feller' is just a casual term for a male, and black, of course, because it was black. But then I cringed. Had the Aboriginal family next door heard?  Would they be offended?  They shouldn't be - there's nothing wrong with being a 'blackfeller,'  not a thing to be ashamed of,  nothing to be insulted about. And yet, they could claim offence and it could even be feasible to make a complaint.  

How very silly.

It also limits big things. There are some very big problems among specific races and cultures now in Australia, some home grown, many imported from overseas. The first requirement of attacking a problem is to define and to understand the problem. That cannot be done if people cannot air the facts in case someone claims to be offended.


Herald Sun columnist Andrew Bolt outside court.
Photo: Vince Caligiuri
The proposed changes came about after the commentator, Andrew Bolt, was deemed to have broken the law when he wrote about fair-skinned people who choose to identify as Aboriginal.

Andrew Bolt’s article (2009)  has not been reproduced here  in case it gets me into trouble as it did Andrew Bolt. In essence, it points out that claiming Aboriginal heritage, no matter how far removed and unlikely, can give real advantages to those who choose to do so. There are jobs and there are awards in the arts only open to Aboriginal people.  Bolt named several individuals who have received such advantages even when their Aboriginal heritage is not readily apparent. I’ve seen claims that there were factual errors in what he said. Maybe there are, maybe there are not.

He was sued.  He lost the case.

But I know it does happen.  
Here are two examples from my own personal experience

1.       An acquaintance of mine once boasted to me that if she chose, she could claim she was Aboriginal because she knew someone who was Aboriginal and who would be prepared to  say that she was also a part of that Aboriginal community. That was one requirement satisfied. She said nothing about the other requirement – an ancestor who was Aboriginal. 

      A few years later, she made her claim that she was Aboriginal. This was 1980s, almost as ‘politically correct’ a time as now.  It would not have been acceptable for the government employee who looked at the claim  to demand further proof  than a statement by herself and by her acquaintance. And it certainly would not have been acceptable to point out her fair skin and red hair, or the fact that she was never known as Aboriginal as a child and nor were her parents.

      So her claim was accepted, she did some sort of course in Aboriginal Counselling, and  then applied for and was appointed to a well paid government job that had been set aside for Aboriginal applicants only.  It only lasted a couple of years  – I don’t know why.

2.       Another acquaintance, an immigrant from Holland. She was married to an immigrant from England. So how did their son manage to be on the government assistance, Abstudy,  rather than Austudy?  (Abstudy was for Aboriginal children.)   I have no idea how she claimed her son was Aboriginal.

 
 We come in all colours.  Colour does not make us unequal.  Sometimes, culture does. We must be able to discuss aspects of our culture that are bad for us and bad for our country. And whenever someone objects, if what was said is factual, then that has to be a total defence.

Some cultural practices are bad.  Simply bad.  Some defend the mutilation of the genitals of girls, for instance, by saying it is 'culture.' Forced marriage, underage marriage - aspects of culture.

from Wikipaedia.
The ideal length for a bound foot was three inches
Remember that the Chinese used to cripple girl children by binding their feet so that they grew up with tiny, dainty feet that men found sexy?  It was culture.  It was condemned, and the practice fell out of favour. No little girls are crippled in that way any more. 

But what if it was happening now?  Would we be afraid to speak of it because that would imply that the Chinese culture was inferior?



We must be able to discuss problems. We must be able to discuss other cultures and what they do right and what we find very wrong. We have to be able to breathe freely. This amendment is sensible, it is just, it is needed.

 

Andrew Bolt concluded in his article:
Let’s go beyond racial pride. Beyond black and white. Let’s be proud only of being human beings set on this land together, determined to find what unites us and not to invent such racist and trivial excuses to divide. Deal?
Sounds a great idea to me.
 
 
 






 


 

 


Sunday, 10 March 2013

What price a child's life?

 

What price a child’s life ?


This is what they always say when they introduce some stupid new law because a child somewhere, died. The latest is a plan to enforce windows that will only open around 10 cms so that children will not use their beds as trampolines and then fall out of the open window. It seems to me that it’s rather foolish to put a bed that close to the window to begin with. The child himself must learn responsibility, not to mention the mother. But no, rather than expecting the parents of children to exercise a little common sense, they’d rather penalise everyone who owns a building with more than one story. The current argument is not whether they should impose this cost on innocent people, but whether it should be on all buildings or only on new buildings. And have they considered that making it more difficult to open a window could make it more difficult to escape a fire? Just another typical knee-jerk reaction.




The laws for swimming pools are the worst, of course. It seems to me that parents of small children should simply not live in houses with swimming pools. It is not the responsibility of anyone but the parents to ensure that your child stays away from my fenced backyard. And is a swimming pool so uniquely dangerous? What about beaches, lakes, rivers, duck-ponds, and fish-ponds?  I think the difference here is that Councils or government would have to pay to fence those off, while it’s fine to target innocent householders with draconian regulations. And besides, it’s a ridiculous thought to fence off every shore-line, every river, every duck-pond or water-hole.  


It is the nature of a child to explore, to play, to play actively and to master his body by active play. It is the only way to learn what he can do and what he cannot do. Modern children though, are not allowed to do what is in their nature.  When I took my pre-schoolers to the primary school for a familiarity session, the waiting mothers casually allowed their children to play on the play equipment. It was what it was for. I was appalled to discover later that the poor school children were only allowed on it when supervised by a teacher, and that was rare. Children these days are not allowed to climb trees, not allowed to wander, not allowed to light bonfires, not allowed to play near water…  And then the poor kids are made to feel bad because they play computer games too much and get too fat.




Children will have accidents. They must not be wrapped in cotton wool. They must be allowed to play and explore, and there is no valid reason why householders should be put to ridiculous trouble and expense to try and keep every child from getting into trouble.  



These school children are being taught to surf.





Active boys are the heroes of my Penwinnard Stories. They have free access to a beach.


This next part is just an ad, so ignore now if you choose.

Look for my Penwinnard Novels
  
or on Amazon or on other bookselling sites. Available in paperbacks or ebooks.